Overview and Principles of Treatment
| Genetics
Movement Disorder | Cognitive Disorder Psychiatric Disorder |
Other
Issues | References
Introduction
The cognitive disorder in Huntington's disease is considered a "subcortical"
syndrome and usually lacks features such as aphasia,
amnesia, or agnosia that are associated with dementia of the
Aizheimer's type. The most prominent cognitive impairments
in Huntington's disease involve the so-called "executive functions" ó
abilities such as organization, regulation and perception.
These fundamental abilities can affect performance in many
cognitive areas, including speed, reasoning, planning,
judgment, decision making, emotional engagement,
perseveration, impulse control, temper control, perception,
awareness, attention, language, learning, memory and
timing.
Several studies have suggested that cognitive and
behavioral impairments are greater sources of impaired
functioning than the movement disorder in persons with Huntington's disease,
both in the work place and at home. In addition, family
members most often report that placement outside the home is
initiated because of cognitive and behavioral deterioration
rather than motor symptoms.
This chapter provides an overview of cognitive
impairments and the related behavior problems that typically
accompany Huntington's disease. In addition, compensation and adaptation
strategies are provided, which physicians may recommend to
patients, families and other professionals.
Disorganization
Difficulties in planning, organization, sequencing and
prioritizing can affect responsibilities at home and at
work. Daily tasks, such as attempts to follow a recipe, to
maintain a daily planner, to complete a list of household
errands, to develop a meeting agenda, or to apply for social
security benefits, become daunting.
TABLE 6: Coping Strategies for Planning
and Decision Making
|
- Rely on routines, which can be easier to
initiate or continue without guidance.
- Make lists which help organize tasks needed
to do an activity.
- Prompt each step of an activity with
external cues (routine, lists, familiar verbal
cues).
- Offer limited choices and avoid open ended
questions.
- Use short sentences with one to two pieces of
information.
|
Many early-stage Huntington's disease patients complain of problems with
organization and report that they just "can't get things
done." There are several ways to compensate for poor
organization, which can be instituted early in the disease.
Routines should be established at work or in the home so
that the environment can provide structure and organization.
Activities should be organized so that each day is basically
the same. For example, 7 a.m. shower, 7:30 a.m. breakfast, 8 a.m.
take bus to work, 8:30 a.m. check mail, 9:30 a.m. dictate letters,
10 a.m. coffee, 10:30 a.m. staff meeting, noon lunch, 1 p.m. return
phone calls, 2:30 p.m. review accounting, 4 p.m. open meeting to
schedule with customers, 5 p.m. take bus home, 6 p.m. dinner,
7 p.m. family time with kids, 8:30 p.m. time with spouse, 9:30 p.m.
read, 10 p.m. lights out. A central location could be
established for posting a daily schedule. Persons who never
before used daily planners or computer calendars may need to
start.
A centralized message center can be used to make
lists and organize tasks to be accomplished each day.
Additional strategies for dealing with poor organization are
offered in Table 6.
Lack of initiation
Some family members complain that the person with Huntington's disease "just sits
around all day and won't do anything." Regulation of behavior
involves getting started, maintaining the desired behavior and
stopping unwanted behaviors. The initiation, or starting of an
activity, conversation or behavior is often compromised in Huntington's disease. A lack
of initiation is often misinterpreted as laziness, apathy or lack of
interest, and may be a reason for poor performance at work.
Once started, persons with Huntington's disease may be able to execute the behaviors
adequately (i.e., compute taxes, calculate sales, administrate
employees, teach school), but may be unable to organize and initiate
the behaviors at the appropriate time. External initiation often
helps the person with Huntington's disease remain active and participate in both social
and work activities. Keeping a daily routine can minimize the need
for internal initiation.
Maintaining the desired behavior is usually
less of a problem for persons with Huntington's disease. If this aspect of regulation
is impaired, however, the Huntington's disease patient may be unable to regulate
ongoing behaviors in an appropriate manner.
Perseveration
Perseveration, or being fixed on a specific thought or action, can
occur when behaviors are inadequately regulated by the brain. Spouses
often report that patients become behaviorally rigid, and tend to get
stuck on an idea or task. Established routines and gentle reminders
of changing tasks can help avoid problems. An activity that is
atypical for the established routine will be particularly stressful
and challenging for the person with Huntington's disease.
For instance, travel out of
town, or a visit to the doctor or dentist, may disrupt a safe
routine. When shifting to a new task, help prepare the person with Huntington's disease
and allow plenty of time for him to adapt to the new idea. There is a
delicate balance of how much preparation is needed. Telling of a
change in plans too early can cause increased anxiety. Typically,
inform the Huntington's disease patient only one day prior to an event or a few hours
before. Allow plenty of time and frequent gentle cues to allow the
shift to take place.
Impulsivity
Some persons with Huntington's disease experience difficulties with impulse control and
may develop problem behaviors such as irritability, temper outbursts,
sexual promiscuity and acting without thinking. Some degree of
impulsivity and dysregulation of behaviors is quite common in Huntington's disease.
Some strategies to help family members and caregivers cope with
impulsivity are addressed below.
|
TABLE 7: Coping Strategies for Impulsivity
|
- Since the person with Huntington's disease cannot control his
responses, a predictable daily schedule can reduce
confusion, fear and, as a result, outbursts.
- It is possible that a behavior is a response to
something that needs your attention. Don't be too quick
to discount it as an outburst.
- Stay calm. This will help you remain able to think
and not react emotionally and impulsively yourself. In
addition, staying calm may help the person calm
down.
- Let the person know that yelling is not the best way
to get your attention and offer alternative methods for
getting your attention.
- Remember, although the things being said are hurtful
or embarrassing, generally the person is not doing this
intentionally. This is the Huntington's disease talking, not your loved
one.
- The person may be remorseful afterward. Be sensitive
to his efforts to apologize.
- Do not badger the person after the fact. It won't
help. Remember, this lack of control, likely, is not by
choice.
- Medications may be helpful for outbursts and sexually
inappropriate behavior. Talk to your physician.
|
Irritability and temper outbursts
One of the most typical complaints we hear from Huntington's disease families is
concern about irritability and temper outbursts. These signs can be
present for a couple of reasons. First, it is important to assess for
depression when increased irritability is reported. Oftentimes,
irritability and temper outbursts diminish when a mood disorder is
treated. Many times, however, irritability or outbursts remain even
in the absence of a mood disorder.
Examination of the underlying causes of irritability and temper
outbursts is helpful in diminishing the frequency and severity of
these behaviors. Persons with Huntington's disease are continually challenged by
previously routine tasks or activities that are experienced as
overwhelming. Huntington's disease results in a progressive loss of abilities that
often "sneak up" on persons with Huntington's disease. Several patients have confided
that "I didn't realize I could no longer do it." Close attention
should be paid to the signals, verbal or nonverbal, that patients are
upset or wanting something, so that they do not get to the stage of
exploding before they receive attention.
Knowledge of the person and sensitivity to his needs means that
some situations can be anticipated and potential frustration defused.
It may be possible to identify situations which trigger frustration
and either avoid them or provide diversional activities. An awareness
of the person's capabilities is very important, so that he is
encouraged to be as independent as possible and allowed to take risks
without risking constant exposure to failure.
Although this encouragement to maintain independence is not always
possible at work, it is critical to encourage in the home. The person
with Huntington's disease should be encouraged to do things for himself and to
participate in primary decision-making as long as possible, except
perhaps in situations where safety is an issue (i.e. driving or
cooking). Family members should be responsible for providing a safe
environment so that no person is ever in danger. Remove dangerous
implements, such as guns, from the house and have emergency numbers
near the telephone.
Listed below are some general strategies for families to employ to
minimize irritability and some coping skills for temper
outbursts.
|
TABLE 8: Coping Strategies for Irritability and
Temper Outbursts
|
- Assess your own expectations regarding the Huntington's disease
affected individual. A family member may be unwilling or
unable to accept the patient's new limitations.
- Try to keep the environment as calm and controlled as
possible.
- Speak in a low, soft voice. Avoid confrontations and
ultimatums. Sit down and keep hand gestures quiet.
- Try to identify circumstances which trigger
irritability and temper outbursts and avoid them.
- Redirect the Huntington's disease person away from the source of
anger.
- Learn to respond diplomatically, acknowledging the
patient's irritability as a symptom of frustration.
|
Perceptual problems
H D causes deficits in spatial perception. The mental manipulation of
personal space is impaired, even early in the disease. For instance,
the judgment of where the body is in relation to walls, corners or
tables may be disturbed, resulting in falls and accidents.
Precautions might include carpeting the floors and removing furniture
with sharp corners to the periphery of the room, where it will be out
of the patient's path. Behavior problems reported by family members
are often due to another kind of impaired perception,
unawareness of changes due to Huntington's disease, which can lead to challenges
in providing care.
Unawareness
Denial is commonly considered a psychological inability to cope with
distressing circumstances. We often see this in situations such as
the loss of a loved one, a terminal disease, or a serious injury.
This type of denial typically recedes over time as the individual
begins to accept his losses. Individuals with Huntington's disease often suffer from a
more recalcitrant lack of insight or self-awareness. They may be
unable to recognize their own disabilities or evaluate their own
behavior. This type of denial is thought to result from a disruption
of the pathways between the frontal regions and the basal ganglia. It
is sometimes called "organic denial," or anosognosia, and is a
condition that may last a lifetime. We recommend that "unawareness"
be used to describe this type of denial in Huntington's disease to distinguish it from
the more familiar kind and to avoid thinking of patients with Huntington's disease as
suffering from a purely psychological problem.
Unawareness often plays a significant role in seemingly
irrational behavior. At first unawareness may be beneficial because
it keeps the individual motivated to try things and to avoid
labelling himself. In this way it may prevent demoralization.
On the
other hand, unawareness may lead to anger and frustration when the
individual cannot understand why he cannot work or live
independently. The Huntington's disease patient with unawareness sometimes feels that
people are unjustifiably keeping him away from activities that he
could do, such as driving, working, or caring for children, and may
attempt to do these things against the advice of family and friends.
This type of unawareness can become dangerous.
Organic denial is also
an issue for health professionals, friends, and family members, who
may delay making the diagnosis or keep the diagnosis from the affected
individual because they are concerned that he "cannot handle it."
Some people interpret the unawareness as a sign that the individual
does not want to know. We have not found that talking about Huntington's disease to a
person with unawareness will cause negative consequences.
|
TABLE 9: Coping Strategies for Unawareness
|
|
Do not make insight the central goal. A person may be
able to talk about his problems without acknowledging having
HD.
Unawareness will not always respond to interventions, and
a person with Huntington's disease may never seem to "accept" the disease.
Counseling may help someone with Huntington's disease come to terms with
the diagnosis but may have little impact on specific
insight.
It may be helpful to develop a contract, even a formal
written agreement, that includes incentives for compliance
but "sidesteps" the awareness issues.
|
In our clinical experience, organic denial is not easily amenable
to treatment or change. Nevertheless, there are different degrees of
unawareness. It may be that the person can talk about her problems,
but not acknowledge that she has Huntington's disease. In such a case, one might try to
address the problems while avoiding discussion of the diagnosis.
Noncompliance with therapy or nursing care should not automatically
be interpreted as intentional. It may be helpful to develop a
contract that includes incentives for compliance. Denial can thus be
sidestepped, while behavioral goals remain the same.
For example, the goal may be to convince an unsafe driver to stop,
rather than to accept the diagnosis, or acknowledge why he must stop
driving.
Attention
There are many different types of attention. In persons with Huntington's disease,
simple attention often remains intact. In contrast, sustained or
complex types of attention become impaired by Huntington's disease. For instance, most
persons with Huntington's disease will experience difficulty with what is called
"divided attention," or the capacity to do two things at once. For
most people, divided attention is impaired when we are tired, sick,
or stressed. In Huntington's disease, divided attention is compromised most of the
time, regardless of extra stress. Consequently, a person may complain
that he can't "pay attention" as well as he used to.
Divided attention is needed to drive a car while listening
to the radio, talking to the kids in the back seat, or talking on the
cell phone. When divided attention is impaired it is recommended that
patients try to do only one thing at a time. For instance, an
HD-affected person should turn off radios, television, and
telephones, and limit conversations while cooking dinner. When
swallowing becomes a problem, mealtime distractions should be
minimized and the patient should concentrate on chewing and
swallowing to limit choking.
Language
Communication, or the transfer of information from one person to
another, requires a complex integration of thought, muscle control,
and breathing. Huntington's disease can impair all three of these functions. There are
two main aspects to communication: getting the information IN
(understanding) and getting the information OUT (talking). Both of
these aspects can be impaired by Huntington's disease, making communication a difficult
task.
The most prominent language difficulties in people with Huntington's disease are (1)
speaking clearly (articulation), (2) starting conversation
(initiation), and (3) organizing what's coming in and going out.
Misarticulation
Motor speech impairments are quite typical in Huntington's disease. Persons with
Huntington's disease have even been accused of being drunk due to their sluggish
speech articulation. A lack of motor coordination causes
difficulties with enunciation and the breath control underlying
speech.
Impaired initiation of speech
Word finding is often impaired, while knowledge of vocabulary
is retained, because it takes the brain much longer to search and
retrieve the desired object. Listeners sometimes fail to wait long
enough for the brain to do its job.
In addition to speed limitations, the brain fails to regulate
the sequence and amount of traveling information, resulting in
impairments in starting and stopping. When language initiation is
compromised by Huntington's disease, techniques such as phrasing questions with
alternate choice answers (e.g., yes or no; lasagna or spaghetti)
may help someone get started or retrieve the desired response.
Disorganization of language content
In contrast to the basic impairments in language output, the
basic capacity to understand language remains relatively intact in
HD. Even in later stages of the disease, language comprehension
may remain when the ability to speak is significantly diminished.
This fact is important to communicate to family members, staff at
care facilities and other professionals involved. Even if a
patient cannot express herself, it is likely that she can
understand what is being said. Difficulties with word usage are
rare in persons with Huntington's disease, as are frank aphasia or impairments in
semantic memory. The trouble that occurs in persons with Huntington's disease is an
inability to organize the outgoing and incoming language,
resulting in miscommunication. To aid the person with Huntington's disease in
organizing language output and input it is best to rely on short
simple sentences and to assess understanding frequently during
important conversations.
Learning and memory
The type of memory impairments found in Huntington's disease consist mostly of
difficulties in learning new information, and in retrieving acquired
information, but not in storage of information. Problems occur in
getting information in and out, due to the slowed speed of processing and the poor organization of information. Several studies have found
that Huntington's disease patients can demonstrate normal memory for information if
offered in a recognition format. If, rather than asking "can you tell
me what time your doctor's appointment is today?," one inquires "is
your doctor's appointment at 10 a.m. or 11 a.m. today?," persons with Huntington's disease
can often answer correctly. Similarly, if patients with Huntington's disease are given
a long list of words to learn and are required to say the words back
freely they perform poorly. But if they are given a list of words and
asked to recognize which ones were on the earlier list they
demonstrate good memory.
|
TABLE 10: Coping Strategies for Memory
|
- Keep day to day activities as routine as
possible.
- Use schedules.
- Use "to do" lists and reminders.
- Offer a list of choices to assist with recall.
- Provide cues to help with the retrieval of
information.
|
It has been observed that persons with severe amnesia such as that
associated with Korsakoff's syndrome, herpes encephalitis, or
Alzheimer's disease can experience defective explicit memory, such as
for names and dates, and intact implicit, or unconscious memory, such
as the ability to tie one's shoes. In contrast, persons with Huntington's disease
typically have impairments in skills that depend on implicit memory.
Driving, playing a musical instrument, or riding a bike are all motor
memories that can be considered implicit, or unconscious. Huntington's disease impairs
this motor memory system, making Huntington's disease sufferers reliant on more
effortful conscious memory systems to drive a car. Consequently,
driving will take much more concentration and effort, resulting in
increased fatigue and irritability.
Timing
Some recent findings have suggested that persons with Huntington's disease have
difficulty with the estimation of time. For instance, persons with Huntington's disease
may be less able to judge how much time has elapsed. Spouses often
complain that their once-punctual spouse becomes frequently late and
mis-estimates how long activities will take. Frequent reminders may
be needed to keep on schedule. It is helpful to allow extra time and
avoid time pressure when possible.
The progression of cognitive impairments
Although performance in IQ tests often remains within the normal
range in the early stages of the disease, cognitive deficits are
evident in speed of processing, cognitive flexibility (or the ability
to shift topics readily) and the organization of complex information.
The most sensitive indicator of early Huntington's disease on the
Mini-Mental State Examination is serial sevens (the ability to
subtract 7 from 100 serially) and the most sensitive subscale on the
Mattis Dementia Rating Scale is initiation (the ability to begin and
maintain verbal and motor behaviors).
There exist few longitudinal studies of the cognitive decline in
HD. Based upon the information available, speed, organization, and
initiation of behavior are impaired in early Huntington's disease, constructional
impairments worsen in mid-stage Huntington's disease, and some abilities remain
relatively spared (memory, language comprehension) even in the later
stages of the disease. Clinically, as the disease progresses, the
severity of cognitive impairments increases and patients are often
unable to speak or communicate their views in late stages.
Your comments and suggestions are appreciated so mail us at
the following address:hdinfo@uiowa.edu
|
|