Overview and Principles of Treatment
| Genetics
Movement Disorder | Cognitive Disorder Psychiatric Disorder |
Other
Issues | References
Introduction
Patients with Huntington's disease who have psychiatric
disorders generally suffer from underdiagnosis and
undertreatment. It is important to remember that psychiatric
problems, particularly depression, are very common and very
devastating in Huntington's disease, but they are also very treatable.
Relieving a depression in someone with Huntington's disease may be the single
most effective intervention a physician can perform.
Psychiatric disturbances in Huntington's disease are varied. Some
patients suffer from conditions such as Major Depression,
Bipolar Disorder, or Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder which are
specific well-described syndromes, found in all sorts of
patients. Many, if not most people with Huntington's disease also experience
less well defined, non-specific changes in personality and
mood, such as irritability, apathy, or disinhibition. Most
of these psychiatric problems are believed to be related
directly to the central nervous system injury caused by Huntington's disease.
This issue is discussed further in the chapter on
cognition.
Specific psychiatric diagnoses
Depression
"Who wouldn't be depressed if they had Huntington's disease?" Actually,
research and clinical experience shows that many Huntington's disease patients are not depressed, and are able to
adapt gradually to having Huntington's disease. Nonetheless, even severe
depression in someone with Huntington's disease is often explained away as
an "understandable" reaction, therefore not requiring
additional treatment. This potential for
overinterpretation exists in a variety of other serious
medical conditions such as AIDS, stroke, and Aizheimer's
disease, which have a high comorbidity with depression.
In fact, those patients who have a depressive syndrome,
even when the depression is "understandable," and even
when there are clear triggers, usually respond to
standard treatments, including medications and
psychotherapy. Because depression in Huntington's disease appears directly
related to the brain disease, pharmacotherapy is usually
indicated.
|
TABLE 11: Signs and Symptoms of
Depression
|
- Depressed or irritable mood
- Loss of interest or pleasure in
activities
- Change in appetite, or weight loss
- Insomnia or hypersomnia
- Loss of energy
- Feelings of worthlessness or guilt
- Impaired concentration
- Thoughts of death or suicide
- Loss of libido
- Feelings of hopelessness
- Social withdrawal
- Psychomotor retardation or agitation
(Based on DSM-IV criteria)
|
Major depression is a clinical syndrome, a constellation
of signs and symptoms which, taken together, suggest the
diagnosis. Use of diagnostic criteria helps to distinguish major
depression from demoralization, transient changes in mood caused
by negative life events, such as bereavement, and from some of the
symptoms of Huntington's disease itself, such as weight loss, trouble with
concentration, and apathy. Patients with major depression have a
sustained low mood, often accompanied by changes in self-attitude,
such as feelings of worthlessness or guilt, a loss of interest or
pleasure in activities, changes in sleep, particularly early
morning awakening, and appetite, loss of energy, and hopelessness.
Depressed patients often feel worse in the morning than in the
afternoon.
In severe cases of depression, patients may have delusions or
hallucinations, which tend to match their depressed mood. A
patient may hear voices berating him or urging him to commit
suicide, or may have the delusion that he will be going to jail,
or that he has killed his family. Depressed patients often display
psychomotor retardation, a slowing of speech and movement as a
result of depression. In extreme cases they can appear stuporous
or catatonic.
It is important to remember that because depression is a
syndrome, with various symptoms and manifestations, the presenting
complaint may be something other than a low mood. For example a
depressed patient may complain of insomnia, anxiety, or pain, with
each problem only a symptom of the depression which is the
underlying cause. It is vital to get the whole story, because
symptomatic treatment for any of these complaints, e.g. sleeping
pills, tranquilizers, or narcotics, could be worse than no
treatment at all.
A specific complaint of depressed mood is not necessary to make
the diagnosis if the patient has the other symptoms. In fact
patients with Huntington's disease often have trouble identifying or describing
their emotional state. Depression in such a patient may be
characterized by changes in sleep or appetite patterns, agitation,
tearfulness, or a drop-off in functional abilities. In such
circumstances the diagnosis should be considered.
In evaluating an Huntington's disease patient with depression the physician also
needs to consider whether some physical problem, other than Huntington's disease,
might be the cause. The patient's medical history should be
reviewed for conditions such as hypothyroidism, stroke, or
exposure to certain drugs associated with mood changes, such as
steroids, reserpine, beta-blockers, and particularly
alcohol.
Pharmacotherapy of Depression
Depressed people with Huntington's disease can usually be treated with the same
agents as any other patient with depression, but certain factors
may make some drugs easier to use. Many new medications have
become available since the first edition of thePhysician's
Guide and the tricyclic antidepressants, while highly
effective, should no longer be considered the standard first-line
choice. Instead, the physician should consider the Selective
Serotonin Re-uptake Inhibitors (SSRIs), such as sertraline
(Zoloft), paroxetine (Paxil), fluoxetine (Prozac), and fluvoxamine
(Luvox). These offer the advantages of low side effect profile,
once-a-day dosing, and safety in the event of overdose. Of these
drugs, fluoxetine has a much longer half-life. If a patient
develops an unpleasant side effect it will take longer to wear
off. On the other hand this may make it a good choice for patients
who sometimes forget to take their medicine.
|
TABLE 12: Key Points in the Treatment of
Depression
|
- Avoid overinterpretation of symptoms.
- Depression is very common in Huntington's disease. Have a low
threshold for diagnosis and treatment.
- Huntington's disease patients are sensitive to side effects. Start
medications at a low dose and increase gradually.
- Ask about substance abuse.
- Ask about suicide.
|
The SSRIs are sometimes stimulating and most patients should take
them in the morning rather than at bedtime. Initial side effects
may be Gl upset or diarrhea, and increased anxiety or insomnia
(although, if they are part of a depression, these symptoms will
eventually respond to the treatment).
SSRI-induced insomnia may respond to 25-50 mg of trazodone
(Desyrel) qhs. A small number of patients will develop sexual
problems on SSRIs, particularly anorgasmia or ejaculatory delay.
These symptoms are highly dependent on the dose. Some people have
asserted that SSRIs, particularly fluoxetine, cause violence or
suicide in psychiatric patients. There is no valid evidence to
support this claim.
Patients with Huntington's disease are sensitive to the potential side effects of
CNS drugs. Any new drug should be started carefully, and increased
gradually. Sertraline 25-50 mg, paroxetine lO mg, or fluoxetine lO mg
are appropriate starting doses. If well tolerated, the dose can be
increased after a few days or a week to sertraline 50-IOO mg,
paroxetine 20 mg, or fluoxetine 20 mg. Most patients will respond to
these doses, but sometimes higher doses will be necessary. As we
will discuss, SSRIs may also be particularly useful for some of
the more nonspecific psychiatric symptoms found in patients with
HD, such as irritability, apathy, and obsessiveness.
Other, newer antidepressants we have used with success in
patients with Huntington's disease include buproprion (Wellbutrin), venlafaxine
(Effexor), and nefazodone (Serzone). These all require dosing
several times a day. A new formulation of venlafaxine, Effexor XR,
may be given once a day, and nefazodone is sometimes given in a
single bedtime dose, despite the short half-life. It is often
difficult for depressed patients, especially those with cognitive
impairment, to adhere to a complex medication regimen. Therefore
these drugs may not be good first choices if there is no
responsible family member who will help make sure that the patient
takes his medicine.
Tricyclic antidepressants (TCA's) such as Nortiptyline
(Pamelor), Imipramine (Tofranil) or Amitryptiline (Elavil) remain
an important class of drugs for depression in Huntington's disease. They can be
given once a day (usually at bedtime because of sedative
properties). Common side effects of TCA's include constipation,
dry mouth, tachycardia, and orthostasis. We tend to favor
nortriptyline over the others because of the relatively low
incidence of these side effects and because of the
well-established range of blood levels which have been associated
with efficacy. It is not necessary to reach the target blood level
if the patient has already responded to a lower dose, but the
availability of meaningful blood levels for the TCA's can serve as
a useful check of compliance, and a reassurance that a patient's
dose is optimal. Since TCA's can worsen conduction delays, an EKG
is indicated prior to treatment if the patient's cardiac status is
unknown. TCA's are extremely dangerous in overdose. As
little as a week's supply may be fatal if taken at once. They are
a poor choice in patients with a history of deliberate overdoses
and may have to be dispensed only a few pills at a time if this is
a concern.
|
TABLE 13: Medications Used to Treat
Depression
|
|
CLASS
|
MEDICATION
|
STARTING DOSE
|
MAXIMUM DOSE
|
ADVERSE EFFECTS
|
|
SSRIs
|
Fluoxetine
|
10-20 mg
|
60-80 mg
|
insomnia, diarrhea, Gl upset, restlessness weight
loss
|
|
Sertraline
|
25-50 mg
|
200 mg
|
similar
|
|
Paroxetine
|
10-20 mg
|
40-60 mg
|
similar, more sedation
|
|
Tricyclics
|
Nortriptyline
|
10-25 mg
|
150-200 mg
|
dry mouth, blurry vision, constipation, hypotension,
tachycardia, sedation
|
|
Other
|
Nefazodone
|
50-100 mg
|
450-600 mg
|
sedation, nausea, dry mouth, dizziness, constipation
|
|
Buproprion
|
100-200 mg
|
300-450 mg
|
seizures, agitation, dry mouth, insomnia, nausea
|
|
Venlafaxine
|
25-37.5 mg
|
225 mg
|
hypertension, nausea, headache, constipation
|
If the patient's depression is accompanied by delusions,
hallucinations, or significant agitation, it may be necessary to
add an antipsychotic medication to the regimen, preferably in low
doses to minimize the risk of sedation, rigidity, or parkinsonism.
If the neuroleptic is being used for a purely psychiatric purpose,
and is not required for suppression of chorea, the physician may
want to prescribe one of the newer agents such as risperidone
(Risperdal), olanzepine (Zyprexa), or quetiapine (Seroquel). These
drugs may have a lower incidence of side effects and appear to be
just as effective. Among the older neuroleptics, high potency
agents such as haloperidol (Haldol) or fluphenazine (Prolixin)
tend to be less sedating, but cause more parkinsonism. Lower
potency agents such as thioridazine (Mellaril) may aid with
overactivity and sleeplessness, but tend to be constipating and
can cause orthostasis.
Benzodiazepines, particularly short acting drugs such as
lorazepam (Ativan) may be another good choice for the short-term
management of agitation. In any case neuroleptics and
benzodiazepines used for acute agitation should be tapered as soon
as the clinical picture allows.
|
TABLE 14: SOME ANTIPSYCHQTIC MEDICATIONS USED IN
HD
|
|
MEDICATION
|
STARTING DOSE
|
MAXIMAL DOSE
|
SIDE EFFFCTS
|
|
Fluphenazine
|
0.5-2.5 mg
|
20-30 mg
|
sedation, parkinsonism, dystonia, akathisia, hypotension,
constipation, dry mouth, weight gain
|
|
Haloperidol
|
0.5-2.5 mg
|
20-30 mg
|
same
|
|
Risperidone
|
0.5-l mg
|
4-6 mg
|
less parkinsonism, less dystonia
|
|
Olanzapine
|
2.5-5 mg
|
15-20 mg
|
less parkinsonism, less dystonia
|
|
Quetiapine
|
25-50 mg
|
500-750 mg
|
less parkinsonism, less dystonia
|
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) has also been found
effective in depressed patients with Huntington's disease. This treatment should be
considered if a patient does not respond to several good trials of
medication, or if an immediate intervention is needed for reasons
of safety. For example a severely depressed patient may be
refusing food and fluids, or may be very actively suicidal. ECT
may be particularly effective in treating delusional depression.
Depressed patients should always be asked about substance
abuse. Substance abuse, particularly of alcohol, can be both a
consequence or a cause of depression, makes treatment difficult or
impossible if not addressed, and significantly increases the risk
of suicide.
Suicide
Depressed patients should always be asked about suicide, and this
should be regularly reassessed. It is a misconception that
suicidal patients will not admit to these feelings. The question
should be asked in a non-intimidating, matter-of-fact way, such as
"have you been feeling so bad that you sometimes think life isn't
worth living?" Or, "have you even thought about suicide?" If the
patient acknowledges these feelings, the clinician needs to ask
more questions to evaluate their severity and decide on the best
course of action. Are the feelings just a passive wish to die or
has the patient actually thought out a specific suicidal plan?
Does the patient have the means to commit suicide? Has she
prepared for a suicide, such as by loading a gun or hoarding
pills? Can the patient identify any factors which are preventing
her from killing herself? What social supports are present? Some
patients, although having suicidal thoughts, may be at low risk if
they have a good relationship with their doctor, have family
support, and have no specific plans. Others may be so dangerous to
themselves that they require emergent hospitalization.
Although there have been cases of non-depressed patients with
Huntington's disease harboring chronic suicidal feelings, we feel that most, if not
all, suicidal patients with Huntington's disease suffer from Major Depression and
can be treated successfully. So as not to miss such cases, it is
helpful to think of all patients with Huntington's disease who are suicidal as
depressed until proven otherwise. If the clinician is unsure, the
patient should be treated presumptively. This is not to say that a
person with Huntington's disease, particularly early in the course of the disease
may not express a fear of becoming helpless one day, or a desire
not to live past a certain degree of impairment. A physician
should listen supportively to these concerns, realizing that most
patients will be able to adapt if they are not suffering from
depression.
Mania
While depression is the most common psychiatric problem in Huntington's disease, a
smaller number of patients will become manic, displaying elevated
or irritable mood, overactivity, decreased need for sleep,
impulsiveness, and grandiosity. Some may alternate between spells
of depression and spells of mania with times of normal mood in
between, a condition known as bipolar disorder. Patients with
these conditions are usually treated with a mood
stabilizer.
Lithium is probably still the most popular mood
stabilizer for people with idiopathic bipolar disorder, but we
have not found it to be as helpful in patients with Huntington's disease. It is not
known why this is the case. Lithium has a narrow therapeutic
range, particularly in patients whose food and fluid intake may be
spotty, but there may be some other aspect to the mood disorders
found in Huntington's disease patients which make them poor lithium responders.
We recommend beginning with the anticonvulsant divalproex
sodium (Depakote) or valproic acid (Depekene) at a low dose such
as 125 to 250 mg po bid and gradually increasing to efficacy, or to
reach a blood level of 50-150mcg/ml. A dose of 500 mg po bid is
fairly typical, but some patients will require as much as several
grams per day.
Another anticonvulsant, carbamazepine (Tegretol),
is also an effective mood stabilizer. This can be started at
100-ZOO mg per day, and gradually increased by lOO mg/day to reach
an effect or a therapeutic level of 5-IZmcg/ml, which may require
a dose of 800-1 ZOO mg/day. Therapeutic ranges for these drugs were
established on the basis of their anticonvulsant properties, so it
is important to remember that a patient may show a good
psychiatric response below the minimum "therapeutic" level (but
generally should not exceed the maximum level in any case).
Both
drugs carry a small risk of liver function abnormalities
(particularly divalproex sodium) and blood dyscrasias
(particularly carbamazepine), and so LFT's, and CBC should be
routinely monitored every few months and clinicians should be
alert for suggestive symptoms. Valproic acid may cause
thrombocytopenia, and both drugs are associated with neural tube
defects when used during pregnancy.
Manic patients with Huntington's disease who have delusions and
hallucinations may require a neuroleptic, and patients who are
very agitated may need a neuroleptic or a benzodiazepine for
immediate control of these symptoms. As discussed for depression,
the doctor may wish to prescribe one of the newer antipsychotics
which have fewer parkinsonian side effects, such as risperidone,
olanzepine, or quetiapine. In cases of extreme agitation, a
rapidly acting injectable agent, such as droperidol (Inapsine) or
lorazepam may be necessary. Finally, ECT is known to be a very
effective treatment for idiopathic mania and should be considered
when other treatments fail, or when the individual is extremely
dangerous.
|
TABLE 15: Medications Used for Mania in Huntington's disease
|
|
MEDICATION
|
STARTING DOSE
|
MAXIMAL DOSE
|
SIDE EFFECTS
|
|
Neuroleptics (see table 14)
|
see table
|
see table
|
see table
|
|
Divalproex sodium
|
250 mg
|
500-2000 mg
|
G.I. upset, sedation, tremor,
liver toxicity, throbocytopenia
|
|
Carbamazepine
|
100-200 mg
|
1200-1600 mg
|
sedation, dizziness, ataxia, rash,
bone marrow suppression
|
Obsessive-compulsive disorders
Obsessions are recurrent, intrusive thoughts or impulses which are
experienced as being senseless, at least initially. A compulsion
is a repetitive performance of the same activity, a stereotyped
routine which must be followed, often in response to an obsession,
such as handwashing because of an obsessive concern with germs.
Obsessions are usually a source of anxiety and the patient may
struggle to put them aside, whereas the acting out of compulsions
generally relieves anxiety and may not be as strongly resisted.
True Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) is rare in Huntington's disease, but Huntington's disease
patients often display an obsessive preoccupation with particular
ideas. Patients may worry about germs or contamination, or engage
in excessive checking of switches or locks. Sometimes patients
will become fixated on an episode of being wronged in the past
(e.g. fired from a job, divorced, driver's license revoked), and
then bring it up constantly, or become preoccupied with some
perceived need, such as a desire to go shopping, or to eat a
certain food.
Serotonergic antidepressants are used to treat OCD and may
ameliorate obsessions and compulsions in Huntington's disease patients that do not
meet the criteria for the full syndrome. The use of the tricyclic
antidepressant clomipramine (Anafranil) has largely been
superceded by the SSRIs fluoxetine, sertraline, paroxetine and
fluvoxamine (Luvox) which have milder side effects and lower
lethality in overdose. Patients may require higher doses than
those needed for depression, e.g. 40-60 mg of fluoxetine. For
relentless perseverative behavior unresponsive to these agents,
one might consider neuroleptics, keeping in mind that the newer,
atypical drugs may be better tolerated.
Schizophrenia-like disorders
Schizophrenia and schizophrenia-like conditions are much less
common than affective disorder in Huntington's disease. The new onset of delusions
and hallucinations should prompt a search for specific causes or
precipitating factors, including mood disorders, delirium related
to metabolic or neurologic derangements and intoxication with or
withdrawal from illicit or prescription drugs.
Once these possibilities of mood disorder, drug intoxication,
and delirium have been considered, neuroleptics may be employed
for Huntington's disease patients with schizophrenia-like syndromes. The doses used
for treatment of psychosis may be somewhat higher than those used
for treatment of chorea. As mentioned before, if neuroleptics are
not needed for the control of involuntary movements, patients may
do better on newer agents such as risperidone, olanzepine or
quetiapine which do not cause as many extrapyramidal side effects.
Some patients will respond completely and others only partly,
reporting that "voices" have been reduced to a mumble, or becoming
less preoccupied with delusional concerns. Patients with delusions
will rarely respond to being argued with, but a clinician may
certainly express skepticism regarding a delusional belief and
explain to the patient that it may be the product of a mental
illness.
Caregivers should be encouraged to respond
diplomatically, to appreciate that the delusions are symptoms of a
disease, and to avoid direct confrontation if the issue is not
crucial.
Delirium
Delirium, an abnormal change in a patient's level of
consciousness, may result from a variety of toxic, structural or
metabolic causes. Delirious patients may have waxing and waning of
consciousness, may be agitated or lethargic, and frequently have
disturbed sleep. Patients in the later stages of Huntington's disease, are
particularly vulnerable to delirium. Common causes of delirium in
Huntington's disease include prescription medications, particularly benzodiazepines
and anticholinergic agents, alcohol or illicit drugs, and medical
problems such as dehydration and respiratory or urinary tract
infections. It is important to ask about over the counter
medicines such as cold tablets and sleep aids, which patients and
families may forget to mention. Subdural hematoma, due to a
recognized or unrecognized fall should also be considered if the
patient suffers a sudden change in mental status.
Delirium can
also come about gradually as an underlying problem worsens. For
example, a dehydrated patient may no longer be able to tolerate
his usual medication regimen. Delirium can also be mistaken for a
number of other conditions in Huntington's disease. As mentioned previously, it may
be accompanied by hallucinations or paranoia.
Clinicians usually
expect delirious patients to exhibit agitation or hyperarousal and
may overlook the delirious patient who is somnolent or obtunded.
Such patients may seem depressed to their families, but when
questioned will not report a low mood.
Physicians should consider a diagnosis of delirium whenever
confronted with an acute behavioral change in someone with Huntington's disease and
should review the medication list, examine the patient, and obtain
necessary laboratory studies, including a toxicology screen if
indicated. Identification and correction of the underlying cause
is the definitive treatment for delirium. Low doses of
neuroleptics may be helpful in managing the agitation of a
delirious patient temporarily.
Psychiatric symptoms not belonging to a specific diagnostic
category
Patients with Huntington's disease may suffer from a variety of
emotional symptoms which do not fit any specific psychiatric
diagnosis, but may nevertheless be a source of distress and a focus
of treatment including irritability, anxiety and apathy. Some of
these symptoms are related to the disease itself, and others can be
seen as a response to changing circumstances, such as a patient who
becomes anxious about going to the market because her involuntary
movements attract attention.
Patients with Huntington's disease may undergo personality
changes, becoming irritable, disinhibited, or obsessional. In some
cases these changes represent an accentuation, or coarsening of
personality characteristics the person already had. Other times they
will be a radical departure from the patient's usual state, which can
be very distressing to families. Families should be reassured, as
patients can usually be helped by better communication, environmental
interventions, and judicious use of medications.
Irritability
Irritability is a common complaint from persons with Huntington's disease and their
families. It is often associated with a depressed mood, but may
also result from a loss of the ability of the brain to regulate
the experience and expression of emotion. Irritability in persons
with Huntington's disease may take the form of an increase in the patients' baseline
level of irritability, or there may be episodes of explosiveness
as irritable responses to life events become exaggerated in
intensity and duration.
Other patients may not be irritable under
most circumstances, but will develop a kind of rigidity of
thinking which will cause them to perseverate relentlessly on a
particular desire or idea, becoming progressively more irritable
if their demands are not met. One woman, for example, insists on
having 10 to 12 varieties of juice in the refrigerator at all
times and was markedly irritable during a recent visit to the
clinic. Her husband had started the car to drive to the clinic and
had refused to go back into the house to get her another glass of
juice. Hours later she was still dwelling on it and kept
interrupting the interview to say that she wanted to go home to
have a drink.
Irritability in Huntington's disease may have a variety of triggers and
exacerbating causes. It is important to understand it in context
and avoid premature use of medications. One must first understand
exactly what the informant means by saying the patient is
irritable or agitated.
Does the patient appear restless? Is the
patient yelling or verbally abusive? Is there potential for
violence? Many factors can precipitate an irritable episode, such
as hunger, pain, inability to communicate, frustration with
failing capabilities, boredom, and changes in expected routine.
Family members and caregivers should learn to respond
diplomatically, appreciating the patient's irritability as a
symptom. Confrontations and ultimatums should be avoided if the
issue is not crucial.
The environment should be made as calm and structured as
possible. Some families achieve this more easily than others.
Family settings in which there are children and adolescents,
unpredictable working hours, noise, or general chaos may lead to
irritability and aggressiveness in persons with Huntington's disease. Caretaker and
family support groups can provide emotional support and are a
forum for sharing strategies that members have found useful in
their own households.
When irritability is severe, or enduring, or is expressed
physically, patients are often described as agitated. A great deal
of overtreatment, particularly with neuroleptics, stems from
continuous use of a drug for an episodic problem. It is
always necessary to revisit the situation and see whether the drug
has actually reduced the frequency of outbursts.
For episodic
outbursts, success often results from combining drug therapy with
a careful analysis of the context and precipitants of the
outburst.
Nevertheless, we have found a number of medications helpful in
treating enduring irritability. Patients may respond to
antidepressants, particularly the SSRIs (sertraline, fluoxetine,
and paroxetine) even if they do not meet all the criteria for
major depression.
The optimal doses for treating irritability are
not known but one should start at a low dose and increase
gradually as in the treatment of depression (see table 13). These
agents may be particularly useful when the irritability seems tied
to obsessions and perseveration on a particular topic. As in the
treatment of depression, improvement may not occur for several weeks.
Mood stabilizers such as
divalproex sodium and carbamazepine have also been helpful and
could be administered as outlined for bipolar disorder (see table
15).
Low dose neuroleptics may be helpful, particularly the newer,
"atypical" ones which have fewer side effects. Long-acting
benzodiazepines, such as clonazepam (Klonopin), starting at low
doses, e.g. 0.5 mg/day, have also been helpful. The clinician must
carefully monitor patients treated with these agents, as
overdosing can lead to falls or aspiration.
|
TABLE 16: Coping Strategies for Irritability
|
- Restructure the person's expectations and
responsibilities to manage frustration. The
environment should be as calm and structured as
possible.
- Respond diplomatically, acknowledging the
irritability as a symptom. Confrontations and
ultimatums should be avoided unless the issue is
crucial.
- Try to identify circumstances which trigger temper
outbursts, and redirect the person away from the
source of anger.
- Family and caretaker support groups can provide
valuable emotional support and are good places to
learn and share effective strategies.
|
Apathy
Apathy is common in Huntington's disease and is probably related to frontal lobe
dysfunction. Apathetic patients become unmotivated and
uninterested in their surroundings. They lose enthusiasm and
spontaneity. Performance at work or school becomes sluggish. The
symptom of apathy can be very troubling to families, if they see
the active person they knew slipping away. It can be a source of
conflict for caregivers, who know the person is physically capable
of activities but "won't" do them.
Families need much education and support in this regard and
should learn to practice a combination of exhortation and
accommodation. While apathetic patients have trouble initiating
actions, they will often participate if someone else suggests an
activity and works along with them to sustain energy and
attention. For example, a man with Huntington's disease had always loved fishing,
but when his brother came to take him fishing for his birthday he
wanted to stay home in front of the television. The brother
insisted, and when they left the house, he had a good time fishing
all day. When he returned, he immediately turned the television
back on.
Apathy can be hard to distinguish from depression. Apathetic
patients, like those with depression, may be sluggish, quiet, and
disengaged. They may talk slowly, or not at all. By and large apathetic patients will deny being sad, but in distinguishing the two it is important to
ask not only about the patient's mood, but about other depressive
symptoms as well, such as a change in sleeping or eating patterns,
feelings of guilt, or suicidal thoughts. Neuroleptics and
benzodiazepines can cause or worsen apathy. The need for these
medications should be reexamined if the patient is apathetic.
|
TABLE 17: Coping Strategies for Apathy
|
- Use calendars, schedules and routines to keep the
person busy.
- Do not interpret lack of activity as
"laziness."
- Patients may not be able to initiate activities,
but may participate if encouraged by others.
- Gently guide behaviors, but accept "no."
|
Depressed patients with apathy should be treated aggressively
for their depression, which may cause the other symptoms to remit.
It can be very difficult to distinguish depression from primary
apathy, but patients with primary apathy sometimes respond to
psychostimulants such as methylphenidate (Ritalin), pemoline
(Cylert) or dextroamphetamine (Dexedrine). These medicines are
highly abusable and may exacerbate irritability.
They should be
used with caution. It may be more prudent to make a trial of a
non-sedating antidepressant, such as an SSRI, first even if the
patient does not seem to meet the criteria for depression, as
these agents have also occasionally been helpful.
Anxiety
Patients with Huntington's disease are vulnerable to anxiety because of life
circumstances, but also because of physical changes in the brain.
Patients may develop a social phobia related to embarrassment
about visible symptoms. As thought processes become less flexible,
patients may be made anxious by trivial departures from the usual
routine. Patients may worry for days in advance about what to wear
when going to the hairdresser or whether to attend a family
function.
In addressing anxiety, attempts should be made to decrease the
complexity of the patient's environment. Stopping a job that has
become too difficult may result in a remarkable decline in
symptoms. Assisting the caregiver in establishing a predictable
routine for the patient is helpful. Some caregivers find it useful
to refrain from- discussing any special events until the day
before they are to occur. Patients who are very fearful of going
to the doctor may need to be told only that they are going on an
errand until they reach the clinic.
Some patients will not improve with counseling and
environmental interventions and will require pharmacotherapy. The
clinician should first assess whether the anxiety is a symptom of
some other psychiatric condition, such as a major depression.
Patients with obsessive-compulsive disorder may be made anxious by
obsessions about danger or "germs," or if their rituals are
interrupted.
Panic disorder, although uncommon in Huntington's disease, is a highly treatable
condition. It is characterized by the acute onset of overwhelming
anxiety and dread, accompanied by physiological symptoms of rapid
heartbeat, sweating, hyperventilation, lightheadedness, or
paraesthesias. Panic attacks usually last only fifteen or twenty
minutes, may begin during sleep, and may result in syncope.
Suspected panic attacks require a good medical work-up, because
most of the other possible explanations for the symptoms represent
highly dangerous conditions. Once these other causes have been
ruled out, the usual treatment consists of SSRIs, sometimes
temporarily supplemented with benzodiazepines. SSRIs are usually
mildly stimulating and may need to start at a lower dose than that
used for depression.
Benzodiazepines should be used judiciously in anxious persons
with Huntington's disease because of the vulnerability of these patients to delirium
and falls and because of their potential for abuse, especially in
patients whose judgement may already be impaired. PRN medications
may have to be controlled by a family member. Some patients will
respond to the non-benzodiazepine anxiolytic buspirone, which can
be started at 5 mg two to three times per day and advanced to
20-30 mg per day in divided doses.
Sexual disorders
Many patients with Huntington's disease become uninterested in sexual activity.
Others may continue to enjoy healthy sexual activity well into the
course of the illness. Occasional patients may desire and pursue
excessive sexual activity or engage in inappropriate sexual
behaviors, such as public masturbation, or voyeurism. The spouse,
usually the wife, may be distressed and fearful because the
individual with Huntington's disease may become aggressive if sexual demands are not
met. Spouses may be afraid to talk about the problem unless
interviewed alone. Interventions are difficult in these
circumstances, probably because of the patient's impaired
judgement and the strength of the drive.
Open communication about
sex between the doctor and the family can help to destigmatize
this sensitive topic. With open discussion among the parties,
distressing sexual behaviors can sometimes be adapted into more
acceptable acts. Patients engaging in these behaviors should be
assessed and treated for comorbid conditions, such as mania. We
have found antiandrogenic therapy helpful in a few of these
cases.
Your comments and suggestions are appreciated so mail us at the following address: anne-leserman@uiowa.edu
Disclaimer: The indications and dosages of this
material have either been recommended in the medical literature or
conform to the practices of physicians expert in the care of people
with Huntington's disease. The indications do not necessarily have
specific approval forth Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for the
indications and dosages for which they are recommended. The package
insert for each drug should be consulted for uses and dosage approved
by the FDA. Because standards for dosage change, it is advisable to
keep abreast of revised recommendations, particularly those
concerning new drugs. Statements and opinions expressed in this book
are not necessarily those of the Huntington's disease Society of
America, Inc. nor does HDSA promote, endorse, or recommend any
treatment or therapy mentioned herein. The lay reader should consult
a physician or other appropriate health care professional concerning
any advice, treatment or therapy set forth in this book.
|
|