Today, both men and women are faced with the pressure to obtain an unreachable
ideal body image. In contrast to women, men tend to focus more on muscularity
and body shape than on weight, according to Patricia Westmoreland Corson,
M.D., internal medicine/psychiatry resident at the University of Iowa Hospitals
and Clinics.
Corson, along with Arnold E. Andersen, M.D., UI professor of psychiatry, discusses
this issue in "Body Image Issues Among Boys and Men," a chapter
in the recently published Body Image: A Handbook of Theory, Research
and Clinical Practice.
"The formation of the unattainable ideal image for both genders
begins in childhood and is reinforced by the media and children’s
toys," Corson said.
Emphasizing the ideal image of thinness for women, Barbie dolls have
grown thinner over the past 40 years, but GI Joe action figures have grown
larger and more muscular, presenting an ideal body image for men. If the
proportions of a 1960s GI Joe were applied to a man who is 5 feet 10 inches
tall, he would have a 44-inch chest and 12-inch biceps. His 1990s counterpart
would have a 55-inch chest and 15-inch biceps, according to Corson and
Andersen’s article.
As boys grow older, the muscular ideal is perpetuated through the media,
including men’s magazines, which present extremely lean, defined
and muscular male models.
"These models are ordinary men made to look like they were carved
out of stone, although the photos were probably airbrushed to create that
chiseled look. That’s just unrealistic," Corson said. "I
don’t think that the editors of men’s magazines have even
recognized this as a problem yet."
While women with eating disorders tend to have numerical goals (for
example, weighing 100 pounds or fitting into a size two), men’s
eating disorders involve a constant competition to stay more defined than
other men. This competitiveness may stem from a power shift in recent
years, Corson said.
"The power dynamic in society is changing, especially in the workplace,
where women are gaining more power," Corson said. "Many men
feel that they are facing new competition, and by bulking up, they can
regain a sense of control as well as convey a sense of power, as the size
of a man’s chest, shoulders and his height all convey physical prowess."
Men may also feel more pressured to be physically attractive now that
women—including their wives and girlfriends—are entering the
workforce in larger numbers. This was less of an issue when women stayed
at home more and were not exposed to other potentially attractive mates,
Corson said.
For many men, eating disorders and body image problems begin as a health
kick, but end up in an unhealthy cycle. Diet and exercise can be beneficial,
however, when these activities become excessive and interfere with a person’s
health and ability to function on a day-to-day basis, it may indicate
the presence of an eating disorder.
Starvation can have serious short-term and long-term complications.
Osteoporosis (the thinning of the bones) has been found in men and women
who restrict their caloric intake. Purging through the use of laxatives,
diuretic abuse or vomiting can lead to life-threatening electrolyte imbalances.
Excessive exercise, especially when coupled with the use of steroids,
can lead to physical injury as well as end-organ damage, and the use of
diet pills (which usually contain stimulants) may lead to sudden cardiac
death. While men can suffer from anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa (binging
and purging) is more common.
"Men have a propensity to become bulimics because a lot of them
are used to eating large quantities of food, and it’s disturbing
for them to be without that," Corson said.
Men can also suffer from body dysmorphia, where they obsess over one
or more body parts. For example, men may have a phobia that their shoulders
are not large enough. This often leads to excessive exercise, coupled
with steroid abuse.
The UI Health Care Adult Psychiatry Clinic offers help for men and women
battling eating disorders and body image problems. Patients initially
are seen at the clinic for a one-to-two hour diagnostic interview, where
they are interviewed by a psychiatry resident or a psychiatric social
worker who specializes in eating disorders, as well as by Andersen. The
interview determines the level of care needed—inpatient, partial
hospitalization or outpatient.
Weight is only one factor in determining a patient’s need, Corson
said. Other considerations include medical problems such as electrolyte
imbalances (brought on by vomiting or laxative abuse) or coexisting psychiatric
conditions, such as depression leading to suicidal feelings.
Following the initial diagnostic assessment, Karen Olmstead, UI psychiatric
social worker, continues to work with these patients, often on a weekly
basis. Olmstead uses cognitive therapy to help them understand their body
image distortions and enable them to follow their eating plan, which is
set up by Cathy Dostal, UI Hospitals and Clinics eating disorder dietician.
Andersen also leads a weekly support group to help men with eating disorders
recognize that they have a disorder and understand how their disorder
is both similar to and different from eating disorders in women. The group
also supports families and helps them recognize the problem as well.
"The best way to prevent an eating disorder is awareness about
the pressures put on both men and women to attain an unreachable ideal
image," Corson said. "It’s unfair that both genders have
to put up with that pressure. No one should grow up being told that they
are not worth very much unless they conform to society’s extreme
ideals."
For more information, contact the UI Adult Psychiatry Clinic at 319-353-6314.
0 is published by Guilford Press. The book is edited by Thomas
F. Cash, Ph.D., professor of psychology at Old Dominion University, and
Thomas Pruzinsky, Ph.D., professor of psychology at Quinnipiac University
and adjunct assistant professor of plastic surgery at the New York University
School of Medicine. |